This is a preview of a draft listing that is not live yet.

72 Gardiners Bay Drive, Shelter Island, NY 11964

30 Photos
$5,990,000 List Price
Off Market *Draft
3 Beds
4.5 Baths
5122 SF
Built In 2004
Listing ID 896937
Property Type House
Township Shelter Island
Hamlet Shelter Island
Total Tax $22,393
Tax ID 0700-001.000-0002-061.000
FEMA Flood Map
Year Built 2004
Associated Documents
Lower Level [View]
First Floor [View]
Second Floor [View]
All Floors [View]
Survey [View]
Virtual Tour


This traditional, with inspiring views of "Bug Light" lighthouse and located on 128-feet of sandy beachfront, is completely pristine and ready for its next owner. The rocking chair porch leads to the front entry and foyer with open water views through a step down living room which has double height ceilings, an impressive wood burning fireplace, and doors to a grandfathered, waterside pool. This flows nicely to a family room which accesses a 215 sq. ft. screened porch and leads to the kitchen, which has double ovens, granite counters, a center island with cooktop, and pass-through service to the adjacent formal dining room and powder room. A first floor primary bedroom is on the opposite side of the home, with a fireplace, two walk in closets and separate powder room and shower. The second floor has a landing and open gallery that wraps around the perimeter of the living room for an especially gracious aspect. Each side of the home is flanked by two particularly generously proportioned en-suite guest bedrooms, with an office in the center. The lower level, which adds another 2700 square feet to the 5122 taxable square feet of the home, features a media room, two bonus guest rooms, a full bath, walk in closet and mechanical/storage room. The exterior is all about the beach and waterfront, with a slightly elevated 16 x 32 Gunite pool set inground with hardwood decking with near perfect views of the sandy beach and Gardiners Bay. Sunrise here is ethereal and the glow of the sunset illuminates the lighthouse directly before you, a rare combination.
Property Details
  • 3 Total Bedrooms
  • 4 Full Baths
  • 1 Half Bath
  • 5122 SF
  • 0.91 Acres
  • Built in 2004
  • 2 Stories
  • Available 12/16/2022
  • Full Basement
  • Lower Level: Finished, Walk Out
  • Renovation: 2700 sf lower level at grade walk out contains two bonus rooms, the second floor has an office with glass doors
Interior Features
  • Pass-Through Kitchen
  • Granite Kitchen Counter
  • Oven/Range
  • Refrigerator
  • Dishwasher
  • Microwave
  • Washer
  • Dryer
  • Stainless Steel
  • Appliance Hot Water Heater
  • Hardwood Flooring
  • Stone Flooring
  • 12 Rooms
  • Entry Foyer
  • Living Room
  • Dining Room
  • Family Room
  • Formal Room
  • Den/Office
  • Study
  • Primary Bedroom
  • en Suite Bathroom
  • Walk-in Closet
  • Media Room
  • Bonus Room
  • Library
  • Kitchen
  • Breakfast
  • Laundry
  • Private Guestroom
  • First Floor Primary Bedroom
  • First Floor Bathroom
  • 2 Fireplaces
  • Forced Air
  • 3 Heat/AC Zones
  • Propane Fuel
  • Central A/C
Exterior Features
  • Wood Siding
  • Asphalt Shingles Roof
  • Detached Garage
  • 2 Garage Spaces
  • Private Well Water
  • Private Septic
  • Pool: In Ground, Gunite, Heated, Fencing
  • Pool Size: 16 x 32
  • Deck
  • Patio
  • Fence
  • Open Porch
  • Screened Porch
  • Covered Porch
  • Driveway
  • Subdivision: Hay Beach
  • Bay View
  • Scenic View
  • Bay Waterfront
  • Water Frontage: 128
Taxes and Fees
  • $22,393 Total Tax
  • Tax Year 2022
Presented By
Saunders & Associates
Office: 631-749-5801
Request More Information
Request Showing
Your Preferred Date & Time
Showing Type:
Listing data is deemed reliable but is NOT guaranteed accurate.
Contact Us
Who Would You Like to Contact Today?

I want to contact an agent about this property!

I wish to provide feedback about the website functionality

Contact Agent
Your Name:
Security: What is 5 plus 4?